Render Comparison Redshift, Arnold, V-Ray, Mantra, RenderMan, Octane
17711 4 0- anon_user_90091072
- Member
- 3 posts
- Joined: 10月 2018
- Offline
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOrPKz1SlYE [www.youtube.com]
REDSHIFT 2.6
RENDER TIME:average of 3 min per frame
ARNOLD 5.2
20 min
V-RAY NEXT
8.5 min
HOUDINI 17.0 MANTRA
60 min
RENDERMAN 22
9 min
OCTANE 4
3min
Render Comparison Redshift, Arnold, V-Ray, Mantra, RenderMan, Octane(Glass, Refraction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJghpp8RVmw [www.youtube.com]
REDSHIFT 2.6
RENDER TIME:average of 2 min per frame
ARNOLD 5.2
11 min
V-RAY NEXT
2 min
HOUDINI 17.0 MANTRA
10 min
RENDERMAN 22
10 min
OCTANE 4
3min
Edited by anon_user_90091072 - 2019年4月28日 00:58:45
- mrCatfish
- Member
- 731 posts
- Joined: 12月 2006
- Offline
- protozoan
- Member
- 1618 posts
- Joined: 3月 2009
- Offline
- anon_user_40689665
- Member
- 648 posts
- Joined: 7月 2005
- Offline
- nisachar
- Member
- 83 posts
- Joined: 2月 2016
- Offline
Thank you for this.
It's possible that the shader setups might be slightly different for each renderer which might explain the discrepancies between each Renderer's shader quality results.
That said, Vray and Redshift, while faster than the others (CPU(+GPU?) and GPU respectively) also look underwhelming esp where transparent Shaders are concerned. This is persistent with my own experiments with these two renderers.
Octane is finicky at times but just like Arnold, I prefer it's out of the box results. Octane's transparent shader results look the sharpest and to me, the most believable. Even Arnold is muddled in some of these results ( not to mention the less than stellar rendering times )
PS: How did you setup Renderman 22 for Houdini? I have installed it but I don't see options that are different than the existing integration of the 20/21 defaults in Houdini.
It's possible that the shader setups might be slightly different for each renderer which might explain the discrepancies between each Renderer's shader quality results.
That said, Vray and Redshift, while faster than the others (CPU(+GPU?) and GPU respectively) also look underwhelming esp where transparent Shaders are concerned. This is persistent with my own experiments with these two renderers.
Octane is finicky at times but just like Arnold, I prefer it's out of the box results. Octane's transparent shader results look the sharpest and to me, the most believable. Even Arnold is muddled in some of these results ( not to mention the less than stellar rendering times )
PS: How did you setup Renderman 22 for Houdini? I have installed it but I don't see options that are different than the existing integration of the 20/21 defaults in Houdini.
Edited by nisachar - 2019年5月23日 13:02:35
-
- Quick Links