Forums 3rd Party No Motion Blur with Redshift

No Motion Blur with Redshift

   12401   7   2
User Avatar
manu3d
Member
39 posts
Joined: 12月 2018
オフライン
 
Please have a look at the ultra simple scene attached.

Motion Blur is enabled in the Redshift ROP, the spinning object has a trail node to add some large velocity vectors, the obj-level container has Velocity Blur enabled... but when doing a RedShift rendering, no Motion Blur in sight. The same scene with Mantra clearly show motion blur.

I must be missing something really really simple, like a typical gotcha... what is it?

Kind regards, Manu

Attachments:
noMotionBlur.hiplc (376.5 KB)

User Avatar
madrenderman
Member
129 posts
Joined: 6月 2016
オフライン
 
I tested your scene and "mesh deformation blur from velocity attribute" was disabled, if you enable it, it works.
But you can use the standard motion blur (without the trail node), you just need to insert "$FF*10" instead of "$F*10" into the transform node to let houdini evaluate subframes.
Also put a normal node before the transform sop otherwise the cubes look weird but it's because normals make them appear blurred.
Edited by madrenderman - 2022年9月17日 01:00:34
User Avatar
manu3d
Member
39 posts
Joined: 12月 2018
オフライン
 
Thank you @madrenderman,

such small things once you know them (and remember them) and yet so time-consuming if you don't!

I'll try and remember next time!

Thank you again!

Kind regards, Manu
User Avatar
viscu
Member
3 posts
Joined: 7月 2023
オフライン
 
I am still super confused. I had similar problems, but even if I download the scene from "manu3d" and activate "mesh deformation blur from velocity attribute" I still don't get any motion blur... This is driving me insane.
User Avatar
madrenderman
Member
129 posts
Joined: 6月 2016
オフライン
 
Try this file, if you hit render you should see the motion blur. No need to activate velocity motion blur on the geo node
Edited by madrenderman - 2023年10月31日 13:46:12

Attachments:
noMotionBlur.hiplc (380.4 KB)

User Avatar
mclinced
Member
4 posts
Joined: 3月 2018
オフライン
 
viscu
I am still super confused. I had similar problems, but even if I download the scene from "manu3d" and activate "mesh deformation blur from velocity attribute" I still don't get any motion blur... This is driving me insane.
Hey, did you found a solution?
User Avatar
mclinced
Member
4 posts
Joined: 3月 2018
オフライン
 
viscu
I am still super confused. I had similar problems, but even if I download the scene from "manu3d" and activate "mesh deformation blur from velocity attribute" I still don't get any motion blur... This is driving me insane.
If you have a simulation or some sort of packed primitives, try to unpack them before rendering. It helps in my case.
User Avatar
3dbrown
Member
9 posts
Joined: 7月 2014
オフライン
 
Just had & solved this issue. It seems that on the OBJ node containing your geo (which in my case has a keyframed animation in a Transform node, followed by a Trail SOP with Compute Velocity) the Redshift options are Transformations Motion Blur and Deformations Motion Blur (plus the Mesh Deformations from Velocity Attribute check box).
Enable Deformations Motion Blur and the deformations from velocity and TURN OFF Transformations Motion Blur.

Attachments:
motion_blur_settings.png (11.6 KB)

  • Quick Links