Soooo difficult to fill a small scale object

   658   5   2
User Avatar
Member
30 posts
Joined: June 2017
Offline

Scene is a bottle with a sphere emitting flip fluid (narrow band).
Bottle is around 60cm radius, 1.2meter high. The target is simple: fill up the bottle and make the liquid set still.
I watched tutorials and tried many setting mixture.
Fill new volume on/off
APIC / Flip
Substep 0.2 to 1
Min Substeps / Max Substeps
Ressed Particles on/off
Suface oversampling 1.5--3.0
Oversampling Bandwidth 1--3.0
Death Threshold 1.5--3.0
Random Seed set $T
Apply Particle Separation on/off
Separation Rate 1--2.0
Particle Separation 0.03--0.003
Gird Scale 1.2--2
Initial Data / Input Type : Particle Fied / Narrow band
Add Divergence Field
Volume Collisions / Division Size 0.01--0.1
Attach pre cache *.sim file in "DOP Network / Initial State"

PC: AMD 3950x , RTX 3090, RAM 128G, Cach disk space 1.5TB available, Project disk space 4TB available.
Houdini 20.0.590 non-commercial.

The scene always always stop fill the object at some point.

Soooooooooo frustrating.
Many thanks for any solutions~~!
Edited by digitalwu - Feb. 22, 2024 23:59:39

Attachments:
stopFill.01.png (190.3 KB)
stopFill.02.png (85.4 KB)
stopFill.03.png (29.8 KB)
stopFill.04.png (40.3 KB)
stopFill.05.png (37.0 KB)

User Avatar
Member
30 posts
Joined: June 2017
Offline
I have tried scale up the scene to between 1m--2m, parameter adjust accordingly.
Same issue happen for bigger scene.
Also tried using the "Particle fluid tank", "Wave tank"...hard to kill those particles outside bottle without affecting the simulation in the bottle as these tanks are flat plane.
Edited by digitalwu - Feb. 22, 2024 23:59:15
User Avatar
Member
679 posts
Joined: Feb. 2017
Offline
Can you post your scene? Otherwise it's hard to help.

Cheers
CYTE
User Avatar
Member
68 posts
Joined: Sept. 2014
Offline
- maybe this will help

https://www.tokeru.com/cgwiki/HoudiniDops.html#flip [www.tokeru.com]
User Avatar
Member
30 posts
Joined: June 2017
Offline
After reading some videos and documents. I found that the Particle Separation, Particle radius scale, Grid scale are the most crucial parameters.
And I found that once they were set. While in running the FLIP dynamics, their parameters can’t be animated to prevent “dissolve volume” due to the particle are too “crowded”.
User Avatar
Member
8554 posts
Joined: July 2007
Offline
digitalwu
I found that the Particle Separation, Particle radius scale, Grid scale are the most crucial parameters.
I'd say just Particle Separation
I have never touched Particle radius scale and keep Grid scale mostly between 2 and 1.5 since they are both relative to Particle Separation
you may not want to just randomly tweak them especially without understanding how exactly it affects your sim

what's more important is to look at the Collision guide on the FLIP Object (not on the static object) and see whether you have enough resolution to define the collision shape
Edited by tamte - March 3, 2024 02:03:57
Tomas Slancik
FX Supervisor
Method Studios, NY
  • Quick Links